Apple Appeals Contempt Ruling in Epic Games Case
Intermediate Level | May 11, 2025
📰 Read the article aloud on your own or repeat each paragraph after your tutor.
Apple Appeals Contempt Ruling in Epic Games Case
On May 5, 2025, Apple filed an appeal against a U.S. District Court ruling that found the company in contempt for not complying with a 2021 injunction related to an antitrust lawsuit by Epic Games. The court had ordered Apple to allow developers to direct users to alternative payment options outside the App Store. However, Apple introduced a 27% fee on such external purchases and used warning messages, termed “scare screens,” to deter users from third-party payment methods. Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers deemed these actions as willful non-compliance and referred Apple and one of its executives to federal prosecutors for a possible criminal contempt investigation.
Ongoing Legal Battles in the Apple Appeals Contempt Ruling Epic Games Case
Apple has denied violating the court’s order and has requested the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to pause the enforcement of the ruling, arguing that the mandated changes would cause irreparable harm to its business operations. In the meantime, Apple faces additional legal challenges, including a class-action lawsuit from app developer Pure Sweat Basketball, which alleges that Apple’s practices led to inflated commissions, causing significant financial damages to developers.
Why This Matters
The outcome of the Apple appeals contempt ruling Epic Games case could reshape how digital marketplaces operate. It challenges how much control a platform like Apple’s App Store can exert over developers and payment systems. A decision against Apple might open the door for more competitive payment options, lower costs for developers, and more consumer choice—setting a precedent for how tech giants must treat app makers around the world.
Vocabulary
- Antitrust (adjective): Relating to laws that prevent monopolies and promote competition.
Example: The antitrust lawsuit aimed to break up the company’s monopoly. - Injunction (noun): A court order requiring someone to do or cease doing a specific action.
Example: The judge issued an injunction to stop the company from enforcing the new policy. - Contempt of court (noun): Disobedience or disrespect towards a court of law and its officers.
Example: The witness was held in contempt of court for refusing to testify. - Appeal (verb): To apply to a higher court for a reversal of the decision of a lower court.
Example: The defendant decided to appeal the court’s decision. - Class-action lawsuit (noun): A lawsuit filed by a group of people with similar claims against a defendant.
Example: The consumers filed a class-action lawsuit against the manufacturer for defective products. - Commission (noun): A fee paid to an agent or employee for transacting a piece of business or performing a service.
Example: The salesperson earned a 10% commission on each sale. - Compliance (noun): The act of conforming to a rule, such as a law or regulation.
Example: The company ensured compliance with the new environmental regulations. - Monopoly (noun): Exclusive control of a commodity or service in a particular market.
Example: The government took steps to prevent the company from establishing a monopoly. - Developer (noun): A person or company that creates software applications.
Example: The developer released a new app that quickly gained popularity. - Third-party (adjective): Involving someone who is not one of the two main people or organizations involved in a situation.
Example: The app allows payments through third-party services.
Discussion Questions (About the Article)
- What are the potential impacts of Apple’s appeal on app developers and consumers?
- How do antitrust laws promote competition in the tech industry?
- What are the ethical considerations for companies when complying with court orders?
- How can class-action lawsuits influence corporate behavior?
- In what ways do court rulings shape the policies of major tech companies?
Discussion Questions (About the Topic)
- How should companies balance profits with fairness to consumers and developers?
- What are some benefits and risks of using third-party payment systems?
- Do you think large tech companies have too much power in the global economy?
- How can users and developers push for more transparency in digital marketplaces?
- What lessons can be learned from legal battles between major corporations?
Related Idiom
“In hot water”
Meaning: In trouble or in a difficult situation.
Example: After the court’s ruling, Apple found itself in hot water over its App Store policies.
📢 Interested in more articles that help you understand current events and improve your English? Subscribe to the All About English Mastery Newsletter at allaboutenglishmastery.com/newsletter!
Follow our YouTube Channel @All_About_English for more great insights and tips.
English 
한국어